With a name like Neversink, one wouldn't think a town would have trouble living up to its name but that certainly isn't the case for this (former) NY town.
Well, when the city of Manhattan is growing so fast that they need more water, the state invokes their "rights" and literally takes a town away from the 3000 people that lived there. That town was called Bittersweet and today it lies under 175 feet of water known as the Neversink Reservoir.